Mind, Body and Soul of a Pastor

When Jesus says, “And you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength” (Mark 12:30), he didn’t say the mind is the most important part of a person. Nor the body, nor the soul. Each aspect plays an essential role in making us human. 

With burnout on the rise among church leaders, it’s important to care for each part while appreciating the fact they influence and interact with one another. Here are three experts’ thoughts on ways to nurture the mind, body and soul in order for the whole person to thrive.

The Mind: A Pathway Toward Resilience

By Mark Mayfield

Is the ministry you feel called to starting to burn you out? If so, you aren’t alone. Barna research stated that in late 2023, 33% of pastors considered quitting full-time ministry. Other research showed that 26% of pastors polled often feel depressed. And in 2024, Barna reported that nearly 1 in 5 Protestant senior pastors in the U.S. (18%) say they have contemplated self-harm or suicide within the past year. 

If I stopped here, this would be a fairly depressing article, but I believe there is and can be hope in this conversation. We need to understand that wholeness isn’t found by attending a retreat, listening to a podcast, or marking off a checklist. The pathway to mental wellness begins with four intentional steps.

1. Develop the right understanding of self in relation to God and others.

We all know the Greatest Commandment text out of Matthew 22:37–40: “Jesus said to him, ‘You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind.’ This is the first and great commandment. And the second is like it: ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself.’ On these two commandments hang all the Law and Prophets.”

I often fail to remember that Scripture wasn’t written with Western Christian thought processes in mind. It was written with a Middle Eastern/Asian framework. What does this mean? 

First, this list isn’t linear. Love God? Got it. Love others? Check. Love self? Um, if I get around to it. 

Second, it is a reciprocal cycle that relies on the health of each component for stability. Therefore, a better understanding of the verse would be: Healthy Relationship with God + Healthy Relationship with Others + Healthy Relationship with Self = A Wholistic Love of God. 

Before you argue that a love of self is selfish, notice I said a “healthy” relationship with self, which selfishness categorically is not.

2. Avoid isolation.

Loneliness is one of the most dangerous traps in ministry. It can be easy to lead others while neglecting your own need for connection, but pastors aren’t designed to be emotional islands. 

One solution to this problem is to have at least five safe people speaking into your life. They don’t have to be in your church, or even in ministry. What matters is that they are safe. They need to be people who respect your confidentiality. They shouldn’t be afraid of your emotions, questions or doubts. They will tell you the truth, even when it is uncomfortable. They need to love you, not just your role, and want to help you return to hope, not just offer pity.

Mark Mayfield, Justin Whitmel Earley & Mark Neal
Mark Mayfield, Justin Whitmel Earley & Mark Neal

Mark Mayfield is an assistant professor of clinical mental health counseling at Colorado Christian University and partners with the American Association of Christian Counselors as the director of practice and ministry development. He served as editor for The Mental Health Handbook for Ministry (Baker).

Justin Whitmel Earley is a lawyer, author and speaker. His latest book is The Body Teaches the Soul (Zondervan).

Mark Neal is the founder of the Clarity Leadership Collective, helping ministry leaders embrace sustainable rhythms and lead from a place of wholeness.

Fight Church: A Fighting Chance

“Here was a people group that wasn’t being served by any form of chaplaincy like many major sports have,” says Pastor Joshua Boyd, of the local MMA community. “And they needed care just like anyone else.”

Perfectly Imperfect Churches

Most of the great breakthroughs and innovative ideas are a result of problems being viewed not as a problem to solve, but an opportunity to make things better.

Nigerian Church Promotes a Deeper Christian Life

A. Larry Ross, who traveled the world for nearly 34 years as personal media spokesman for evangelist Billy Graham, says the new epicenter for evangelism is the Global South and Nigerian evangelist William Kumuyi as the pastor of “the largest church of which most American Christians have never heard.”