10 Burning Questions About Church Attendance in the New Normal

Talk to any church leader over the last decade, and they’ll tell you it feels more challenging than ever to get people to come to church on a Sunday. Talk to any leader who is reopening his or her church, and they’ll tell you it’s even harder now. Current in-person attendance levels appear to be […]

Talk to any church leader over the last decade, and they’ll tell you it feels more challenging than ever to get people to come to church on a Sunday.

Talk to any leader who is reopening his or her church, and they’ll tell you it’s even harder now. Current in-person attendance levels appear to be almost universally sparse.

Even in growing churches, the competition for peoples’ time, attention and devotion seems to get more intense every year.

You’ve felt it, too.

So, what’s up? And where is future church attendance heading?

I’m a firm believer in the future of the church and the gathered church. It’s here to stay not because we always get it right, but because the church is Jesus’ idea, not ours.

Still, with everything in the culture changing, how do you navigate toward a better future?

One step is to start asking solid questions.

Why? Because usually the future isn’t pioneered by the clarity of the answers nearly as much as it by the quality of the questions.

Ask the right questions, and you’ll eventually get the right answers. Fail to ask the questions, and you’re sunk.

Here are 10 questions worth asking.

Long-time readers might recognize some of this. I actually did the original version of this post back in 2018 long before anyone imagined a world disrupted by a virus, but crisis accelerates things.

As important as questions about church attendance were before, they’re even more urgent and critical now.

So, with that in mind, here are 10 really big questions about future church attendance as we move into a whole new world.

1. Will Infrequent Church Attendance Become the Universal Default?

If you grew up in church, you were likely raised never to miss a Sunday. Long before COVID, those days were already pretty much gone. I outline 10 reasons for that here.

Prior to the COVID disruption, frequent church attendance (say 2–3 weeks a month) seems to be most prevalent among:

• Volunteers
• Long-time (and older) church attendees
• Families with very young children
• Some new attendees and new Christians (at least for a season)
• Quite honestly, lower-income families for whom travel is not an option

For everyone else, regular church attendance is giving way to non-engagement or online attendance.

As infrequent in-person attendance becomes more normative, it raises a series of other questions.

Hunch

Infrequent church attendance is usually a sign that people don’t see value in what you’re doing. And that’s a problem.

When parents who never ever miss their kids’ soccer practice regularly miss church, it’s a sign that they’re more engaged in soccer than they are in church. In other words, they just don’t see the value in attendance.

Now that people have had a few months of digital access, this trend will be even harder to combat.

Want to drive engagement? Here are some ideas.

2. Does Infrequent Attendance Lead to Lower Devotion Among Christians?

Some might argue frequent church attendance is not an indicator of devotion to Christ. But the bigger question is Is infrequent church attendance a sign of lower devotion to Christ?

Obviously, there is nothing that inherently says that’s the case, but generally speaking, people are less committed to things they attend less often.

Naturally, the goal of faith is to get people to commit to Jesus, not to a local church, but still, as I outline here, Christ and his church are intricately connected.

Add to that the data that 48% of former churchgoers didn’t attend a single online service when church facilities were closed is starting to paint a picture of attrition.

Consider this: Skipping a weekly date with someone you’re supposed to be in love with is usually a sign of something deeper.

Most often, attendance issues signal discipleship issues. That’s true for both online attendance and in-person attendance.

People usually commit to things they’re devoted to. Until they’re no longer devoted to them.

If you think you can be a devoted follower of Jesus and opt-out of the church, here are some thoughts on that (the comments will curl your hair).

Hunch

Infrequent attendance is almost always a sign of sliding devotion. You participate in the things you value most.

3. Will Online Church Replace In-Person Attendance for Many?

So, if people aren’t attending church as regularly anymore, even after a vaccine (which seems likely), what’s the new default?

From Outreach Magazine  How to Face Tough Conversations

The last decade has seen an explosion of online options for Christians, most of which are free: From social media to podcasts and to services streamed both live and on demand.

And the pivot to online for most churches in March 2020 just accelerated that.

The opportunities are endless and will only grow from here.

Even if your church doesn’t have any online presence, don’t worry—thousands of other ministries do. There’s no way to shield your congregation from a changing world.

And actually, come to think of it, there’s shouldn’t be. The church has always adapted to a changing world because Jesus loves the world.

If you’re in the early days of being a digital church, here are 8 tips on how to lead digitally.

Hunch

While I think that (at least at this point) increased in-person engagement almost always leads to higher devotion, for some people online will be their only form of church.

I don’t love this, for reasons stated elsewhere in this post, but if you ignore your online strategy, you lose the chance to reach new people, even if it means some of your less-devoted people step back.

4. Does Online Participation Feed Consumption or Drive Engagement?

One of the key goals for Christians is to engage the mission in front of us: To share the love and salvation of Christ with the world.

But does online participation drive Christians into deeper engagement with that mission, or does it drive us deeper into consumerism?

The challenge with technology, of course, is that we are both its parent and its child. We shaped it, but we’re unclear on how it’s shaping us.

So, given the rise of digital options, are Christians increasingly seeing their faith as something to be consumed?

The gospel by nature demands sacrifice, engagement and risk.

Christianity, at its best, has never been about consuming much and contributing little. We shouldn’t start now.

Hunch

When you design your online strategy, you can shape it to fuel consumption or to fuel engagement.

While many churches will shape it to fuel consumption, the more effective churches will shape it to fuel engagement.

To drive engagement: Make it interactive, get people to take steps, build community and equip people to grow in their faith by things other than just a constant drop of more content consumption.

5. What Happens to Evangelism in a Low Attendance World?

Of all the things that concern me most about lower attendance patterns, this one is the highest on my list.

If you’re consuming your faith online and only attending sporadically, how do you invite your friends into that? You can, but the share link isn’t enough.

Sharing a YouTube link on your profile is not the same as personally sharing your life with a friend.

Sure, theoretically, you can share your faith around a kitchen table. But let’s be honest, not many people actually do that. And something tells me that most people who attend infrequently rarely share their faith.

Christians should live like the good news is good, not just for them, but for everyone.

Hunch

Many Christians will continue to see their faith as something to be enjoyed, not shared. But they won’t be the future church.

The future church will be followers of Jesus who unite around a mission to change the world through the love and hope of Christ.

Church leaders who realize their new job is to equip people to live out their faith at home, in their neighborhood and at work will ensure that evangelism continues and perhaps even grows.

6. What Happens to Discipleship in a Virtual Environment?

Christian maturity is not marked by how much you know, it’s marked by how much you love.

And love has an outward thrust.

Sure, to grow as a disciple you need to have some knowledge. So listen to messages and podcasts, take online seminary classes … do what you need to do.

Consumption has never been the goal of true discipleship. Jesus never asked you to be a disciple; he called you to make disciples.

Hunch

The future church will be filled with Christians who realize they’re called to make disciples, not just be disciples.

From Outreach Magazine  7 Questions to Ask When Starting a Church Planting Network

Churches that help their congregation do this will prevail.

7. How Much of a Virtual Experience Actually Translates?

With almost every congregation now streaming their services, it raises the question of what happens on the other end?

First, as we all now realize, the attention span of viewers and listeners is fractured and intermittent. Watching while running on the treadmill or having kids running around the kitchen chasing their siblings is not the same experience as being in the room live when something is taking place.

Sure, people have been distracted in church for centuries, but it’s a different kind of distraction.

Second, even if you sit in rapt attention to what’s being streamed on your device, is it the same as being in the room? If you only watched online for a year or attended for a year, would your faith be different?

These are questions we don’t know how to answer and realities leaders will have to engage.

Hunch

Because so much online content consumption is often done while people multitask, it will lead to a distracted discipleship unless leaders decide it won’t. The key, once again, is to get online viewers to engage.

The post on 7 NEW Disruptive Church Trends can help you formulate a strategy.

8. Is a Digital Relationship With Christianity Enough?

If physical attendance continues to decline and digital engagement increases, will it be possible to have 100% or near 100% digital relationship with Christianity, much the way you have a completely virtual relationship with gaming, movies or Hollywood?

I really think something gets lost by a mainly digital experience.

A high percentage of couples today meet online. But no couple who meets online wants to stay online: The goal is to meet in person and (maybe) start a life together. Should Christians be different?

If the goal is to do life together, to engage in a mission together, to quite literally change the world together, well … that involves actual human relationships.

But in a world where more and more are choosing virtual connection over real, we’ll have to see what that produces.

Hunch

Forward-thinking churches will realize that gatherings don’t always need facilities and foster home groups, pop-up gatherings and regional connections that foster in-person community facilitated by the church.

This could happen nationally or globally because, as you know, digital church scales in a way that physical church just can’t.

9. What Happens To Kids Whose Parents Only Attend Online?

This one bothers me more than most. Parents will often skip out on attending church because they’re busy or want a day off.

And parents can easily catch up on a message and maybe even still get to a small group.

But what about kids?

We’ve built a relational ministry at our church for all ages based on the Orange strategy and curriculum because, well, I think the Gospel is inherently relational.

You can’t download a relationship or a friendship.

When parents skip church, kids lose far more than their parents.

What happens to a generation of kids who grow up relationally disconnected?

Actually, I think we’re seeing the results of that already. Just read the news.

Hunch

Again, some churches will figure out digital ministry that enables virtual and real-life relationships, even if they happen off Sunday.

10. Will Fragmented Individual Believers Carry the Mission Forward?

Whether the future trends are toward more online engagement or just more sporadic attendance with no online supplementation, the question is whether fragmented individual believers will carry the mission forward?

The church has always been strongest when it’s been a movement of people gathered around a common set of mission, vision, values and strategy.

The hyper-individualism of our current culture (I’ll do what I want when I want to) runs at crossed-purposes to the Gospel and the mission of the church.

I realize many Christians argue they’re done with church, but that still doesn’t change my view that the only one who believes Christians are better off alone is the enemy.

Hunch

I know I’m repeating myself here, but forward-thinking churches will enable physical gatherings that happen in their buildings, but also far beyond their buildings.

Read more from Carey Nieuwhof »

This article originally appeared on CareyNieuwhof.com and is reposted here by permission.