Why We Should Value the Message Over Metrics on Social Media

One of the great mistakes of the social media age is obsessing over metrics at the expense of ideas. There are so many digital tools today that analyze our posts on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and others that we’ve become mesmerized at numbers rather than impact. But wait—before you say “Numbers are impact”—let me explain:

I’m noticing the situation with many church, ministry and nonprofit communications teams who constantly remind the pastor or leader about the organization’s social media metrics. With great enthusiasm, they do their best to impress leadership with followers, engagements and other positive stats.

That’s nice, and don’t get me wrong—we do want people interacting and engaging with your posts. However, I’d also like to see more communications teams sweating the message.

Yes, it’s the pastor or leader’s job to come up with the message, and the communication team’s job to share and measure it. However, don’t get so caught up with tracking that you start ignoring other important issues of creativity and excellence.

As we’ve seen so many times, when it comes to metrics, gaming the system is pretty easy. There are plenty ways to jack up the numbers, order more of the pastor’s books, buy followers, or otherwise make the social media numbers look great. But my question is simple:

What are we saying? What is the message we’re sharing? What’s the quality of that message? What’s the level of the writing, the creativity or the thinking behind it?

Has the fact that someone clicked on your Scripture post actually changed their life?

I would far rather have a small group of enthusiastic social media followers than a massive group of followers who don’t really care. Find your voice. Deliver compelling messages. Create posts that people can’t forget.

Focus less on hitting metrics, and more on changing people’s lives.

Phil Cooke
Phil Cookehttp://cookemediagroup.com

Phil Cooke is a filmmaker, media consultant, and founder of Cooke Media Group in Los Angeles and Nashville. His latest book is Church on Trial: How to Protect Your Congregation, Mission, and Reputation During a Crisis. Find out more at PhilCooke.com.

Dallas Jenkins: Seeing in the Dark

Dallas Jenkins’ faith shaped his journey as creator of The Chosen, inspiring believers through storytelling, perseverance, and a vision for faith-driven media.

Morningside Bible Church: Biker Sunday

“We’re trying to establish relationships. We think that if [bikers returning to our church] didn’t happen this year, then maybe they’ll come back next year, feel more comfortable, and then come out for something else.” —Motorcycle enthusiast Duane Kraayenbrink

John Mark Comer: The Apprentice

John Mark Comer shares his insights on spiritual formation, ‘apprenticeship’ with Jesus, the cultural discipleship crisis, and how ancient Christian practices can renew modern faith.