What does drinking have to do with reopening the church? Since this is already a divisive conversation, I will use a real-life illustration to explore why these transitions are so challenging for leaders.
When I first entered the ministry, it was common to hear arguments against any use of alcohol. For many, total abstinence was viewed as the ultimate sign of spiritual maturity and holiness. Years later, the pendulum swung; it became common in other circles to advocate for drinking as a sign of maturity, viewing it as a proof of Christian freedom.
In both cases, the handling of alcohol became a false litmus test for spiritual health. Whether claiming holiness through abstinence or freedom through consumption, both views placed identity in the wrong source. Christ, not our dietary choices, is the true source of our holiness. When we replace Him with external rules, we drift into legalism. This shift also creates a fragile unity based on shared habits rather than shared faith. As leaders navigate today’s complex climate, asking future-focused reopening questions is essential to maintaining a Christ-centered community.
And now here we are talking about when church gatherings should resume, and the timing of when church gatherings should resume is becoming more and more a divisive conversation.
The moment feels really similar, as if we have been here before. Only this time the posturing and conversations are not developing over the course of a few years, they are happening in the course of a few weeks. And this time is not alcohol proving one’s holiness or freedom, it is opening a church’s gatherings to prove one’s belief in religious liberty or delaying opening to prove one’s concern for neighbor. It is opening church gatherings to show “we are bold” or not opening to “show that we are wise.” Most egregious are the hints that one choice is what love for God and love for others really looks like, as if the other choice is somehow less Christian. In other words, “Those not handling the situation as we are handling the situation must not love Jesus as much as we do. Pray for them.”
How tragic it will be if we send the signal to our kids, to our churches, and to our neighbors that our re-opening plans is what makes us right with God. Our work. Our wisdom. Our ideas. What a foolish way to upend the message of the Christian faith and put ourselves and our work at the center instead of the finished work of Jesus. How tragic it will be if we build unity based on reopening plans instead of on Christ.
Leaders, as you make decisions as the Lord leads you and your team, please be cautious that you don’t use your plans as the ultimate source of unity or as what proves how much you love God. Please be cautious to not demonize another viewpoint, even in subtle ways. By God’s grace, perhaps we can work to not allow this extremely challenging and unprecedented decision to become a point of divisiveness among God’s people. We are seeing divisiveness on the rise in our country, and the church must offer a beautiful alternative. As my friend Ed Stetzer has said: A divided world needs a united church.
This article originally appeared on EricGeiger.com and is reposted here by permission.